Rustic Italian Steakhouse Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Butter

By , Test Kitchen Director · Reviewed by AislePrompt Editorial · ·

A hearty pan-seared ribeye steak finished with a rich garlic herb butter that melts into the juicy meat, perfect for a cozy Italian steakhouse dinner at home. This italian-inspired beef ready in about 45 minutes pairs ribeye steak, 1.5-inch thick, kosher salt, freshly ground black pepper for a weeknight-friendly dinner that comes together with one pan and minimal cleanup. Each serving lands at about 700 calories and feeds 2, so it slots cleanly into a weekly meal plan and pairs well with a quick salad or grain on the side. Tap "Plan a meal with the AI" below to drop this recipe into your week and send the ingredients straight to Instacart. Nutrition values are approximate, calculated from USDA FoodData Central (fdc.nal.usda.gov) — verify against ingredient labels for any health-driven dietary plan.

Prep: 35 min Cook: 10 min Serves 2 Italian cuisine 700 cal/serving
Build a week of meals around this recipe → Shop this recipe on Instacart → Shop equipment ↓

Ingredients

Equipment for this recipe

Top-rated tools to make this recipe successfully.

More Knives & cutting boards → Shop all kitchen tools →

Instructions

  1. Step 1: Remove 16 oz ribeye steak from refrigerator and pat dry. Season both sides evenly with 1 tsp kosher salt and 1 tsp freshly ground black pepper. Let rest at room temperature for 30 minutes.
  2. Step 2: Heat 2 tbsp olive oil in a heavy skillet over medium-high heat until shimmering, about 2 minutes. Add the steak and sear without moving for 4 minutes until a deep brown crust forms.
  3. Step 3: Flip the steak and add 3 tbsp unsalted butter, 3 smashed garlic cloves, 2 rosemary sprigs, and 2 thyme sprigs to the pan. Tilt the pan slightly and spoon the melted butter and herbs over the steak continuously for 3-4 minutes for medium-rare doneness.
  4. Step 4: Remove the steak from the pan and rest on a cutting board for 5-7 minutes to allow juices to redistribute before slicing and serving.

Frequently asked questions

How long does Rustic Italian Steakhouse Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Butter take to make?

Total time is about 45 minutes (35 min prep + 10 min cook). Most home cooks find this fits comfortably into a weeknight; double the batch on Sunday for two dinners.

How do I store leftover Rustic Italian Steakhouse Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Butter?

Cool to room temperature within 2 hours, then store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4 days. Reheat covered in a 350°F oven for 10-12 minutes, or microwave at 70% power in 60-second bursts to keep ribeye steak, 1.5-inch thick from drying out.

Can I substitute ingredients in Rustic Italian Steakhouse Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Butter?

Yes — most ingredients in this recipe have flexible swaps. For oil, use any neutral high-smoke-point oil (avocado, grapeseed, refined coconut). For aromatics, dried herbs at ⅓ the volume of fresh work in a pinch. The full ingredient list is shoppable on Instacart so you can see substitutes in real time.

How do I scale Rustic Italian Steakhouse Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Butter for a different number of people?

The recipe is written for 2 servings. Multiply each ingredient by (your serving target / 2). Cook time stays roughly the same up to 2x; for 3-4x batches, switch from a skillet to a sheet pan or stockpot so the food isn't crowded — overcrowding steams instead of browns.

What goes well with Rustic Italian Steakhouse Pan-Seared Ribeye with Garlic Butter?

Italian beef like this pair well with a simple grain (rice, couscous, or crusty bread), a quick salad with acid (lemon vinaigrette, pickled onions), and a pan sauce or yogurt-based dip. Tap "Plan a meal with the AI" to get specific side suggestions.

Related recipes